Parishioners of the Blessed Virgin Mary Mother of God Church, a Society of St. Pius X, in Syracuse were vocal throughout the month of July in opposition to the piece, which used a Coca-Cola bottle to represent the body of the Virgin of Guadalupe. A petition with 78 signatures and at least two formal requests to remove the piece were submitted to the library board, which denied the request and left the piece on display.
The group, which is not affiliated with the Syracuse Diocese, walked up and down Maple Street Wednesday evening reciting the Rosary for Reparation. Some members of the group carried religious symbols.
Siena Halligan, of Syracuse, had brought her four children, ages 4 to 9, to the protest and took them inside the library to show them Keil’s work. She explained to them that it was disrespectful that the artist used a soft drink bottle to represent the body.
Marcellus resident and regular MFL patron Danielle Jacobs was leaving the building shortly after 7 p.m., when the protest began. She said she had heard about the controversy, but didn’t the piece personally insulting.
In fact, Jacobs was glad to see a religious icon being displayed in a public place like the library.
Michael Brown, president of the MFL Library Board, said the board has a system in place for situations where patrons find material in the library objectionable. The “Reconsideration of Materials” form can be submitted by patrons to request the board consider removing a specific material from the facility.
“It’s very, very important to have a system in place,” Brown said, adding that libraries often by nature have materials that some people might find offensive.
Brown said the library had not been contacted directly by the BVM group, and had not been made aware of any plans to protest the artwork.
In spite of the objection, Brown said it’s business as usual at the library.
“Our director has observed that, with the exception of the petitioners and a few phone calls, the vast majority of our visiting patrons are using and enjoying the library as usual with very little negative discussion concerning the art display,” Brown said in an e-mail. “Our patrons are reading, working, studying, using the computers, and enjoying a busy schedule of programming for the young and adults alike.”
